
Photo: Win McNamee / Getty Images
According to Reuters and the Associated Press (AP), the leaders discussed nuclear disarmament, the war in Ukraine and international security. However, despite the historic nature of the talks, observers do not expect any rapid breakthroughs: the positions of the three powers on key issues diverge significantly.
At the start of the meeting, each of the three leaders made opening remarks in which they highlighted the significance of the event. “We are truly making history,” Reuters quotes Trump as saying. “Never before has peace been achieved by turning down opportunities for engagement.”
Russian President Vladimir Putin noted that the three countries share “many common interests in resolving regional conflicts, including, of course, the conflict in Ukraine”.
The host of the meeting, Xi Jinping, did not mention Ukraine directly, but stated: “History teaches us that when great powers live in harmony, peace and tranquillity reign. When they come into conflict, the world is plunged into chaos.”
The first trilateral meeting between the leaders of the US, Russia and China took place on the sidelines of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) summit. The international press has focused primarily on the prospects for nuclear arms control, the possibility of resolving armed conflicts, and the risk that the interests of other countries may take a back seat in the dialogue between the great powers.
China’s leader called for peace and a diplomatic resolution
Chinese President Xi Jinping emphasised international stability and the need for political solutions to conflicts.
“We will hold discussions on promoting world peace,” said Xi Jinping, President of the People’s Republic of China, at the start of the meeting, according to the Associated Press.
According to the Chinese state news agency Xinhua, Xi also called for the prohibition and elimination of nuclear weapons, with the ultimate aim of creating a world free of nuclear arms.
Reuters quotes another statement by the Chinese leader: China, Russia and the US must continue to encourage the parties to the conflicts to engage in negotiations and resolve disputes through political and diplomatic means.
For China, the meeting also has diplomatic significance: Beijing is acting as a platform for negotiations between the other two global powers, whilst at the same time seeking to strengthen its own status as one of the centres of international politics.
The US President once again expressed optimism regarding a swift resolution to the conflict in Ukraine. “President Putin and I have already discussed this conflict at length today. And it seems to me that we are moving in the right direction. I hope that President Putin and the Ukrainian side would like to bring this conflict to an end,” RBC quoted him as saying following the bilateral meeting between the US and Russian leaders.
Shared responsibility for security
Overall, all three summit participants agreed that the US, Russia and China bear a special responsibility for international peace and security.
“Our three countries bear joint responsibility for maintaining peace and security,” The Guardian quoted Vladimir Putin as saying.
According to the publication, the Russian leader also proposed discussing global and regional relations, as well as energy security.
Prior to the trilateral talks, Putin held a separate meeting with Trump. According to Yuri Ushakov, the Russian president’s aide on foreign policy, the main topic of their conversation was the war in Ukraine. The Kremlin spokesperson also described the Russian leader’s mood after the meeting as “simply excellent”.
Why analysts do not expect a rapid breakthrough
Despite the historic nature of the event, the international media emphasise the difference between the symbolic significance of the meeting and its potential practical outcomes.
Daryl Kimball, Executive Director of the Arms Control Association, quoted by the Associated Press, believes that the talks could, at best, mark the start of a longer process of discussions on reducing nuclear arsenals.
“We need more than just a diplomatic show and photo opportunities for Trump, Xi and Putin at the APEC summit,” Kimball said. In his view, a single meeting is unlikely to lead to any significant breakthroughs.
The Guardian also highlights the differing interests of the participants. For Trump, the priority is the opportunity to achieve a notable diplomatic result. Russia is keen to discuss the war in Ukraine, whilst China is not keen to take on the main responsibility for resolving it.
Analysts view the very fact that Xi Jinping has managed to bring the American and Russian presidents together around the same table as one of the political benefits of the meeting. However, this symbolic success does not yet mean that agreements have been reached.
The concerns of Ukraine, Europe and other US allies
A separate theme in Western media reports is the absence from the negotiating table of Ukraine and the European states with a direct stake in the outcome of the war.
Volodymyr Zelenskyy, the President of Ukraine, had previously warned of the risk of a repeat of the scenario of the 1945 Yalta Conference, when the great powers determined the parameters of Europe’s post-war order. The comparison with Yalta reflects Kyiv’s fear that Ukraine’s fate may be discussed without the country’s full participation.
Trump’s talks with Putin and Xi are taking place without the participation of Ukraine and the US’s European allies, even though their interests are directly affected by potential decisions on security and the war, notes The Washington Post in this regard.
For its part, Axios reports on the concerns of European diplomats regarding possible surprises during the talks. One European diplomat quoted by the publication said: “Every time President Trump speaks to or meets with Putin, it turns out to be bad news for Ukraine and Europe. We are preparing for anything.”
The global economy is on tenterhooks
The talks are significant not only for military and political security. Serious disagreements remain in relations between the three countries over trade, technology, energy and access to strategic resources.
Reuters draws attention to the situation surrounding the Strait of Hormuz, through which a significant proportion of the world’s oil supplies passes. Trump stated that he and Xi Jinping are in favour of maintaining the free flow of oil through the strait, which would be disrupted by a war with Iran.
Technological rivalry between the US and China remains a further factor. In particular, US restrictions on the supply of advanced chips and issues regarding Chinese companies’ access to artificial intelligence technologies are complicating trade relations between the world’s two largest economies.
However, the trilateral meeting does not automatically resolve existing disagreements. For business and global markets, it is concrete decisions on trade restrictions, energy supplies, sanctions and arms control – rather than mere declarations of intent to cooperate – that will have practical significance.
Consequently, the international press highlights three main outcomes at this stage: a demonstration of the leaders’ willingness to engage in direct dialogue; confirmation of differences over nuclear disarmament and Ukraine; and heightened concerns amongst countries not participating in the talks but which may face their consequences.
However, none of the three leaders has yet issued any statements or comments on the outcome of the meeting. It is expected that a joint statement will be agreed upon, and press briefings by the leaders are also possible. At the time of writing, none had taken place.
Therefore, a final assessment of the meeting can only be made once the official outcomes have been published, specific agreements have been reached, and it has been confirmed which statements will be backed up by practical action.
Follow our updates
Have information for the newsroom? Share it with Logos-Press




























Comments
0No comments yet. You can start the conversation.
Comments are open to readers with a Logos Press account.
Sign in to comment